Hitler's racial policy and his final solution to the Jewish question (Holocaust) is part of the Sec 3 history syllabus. This topic is both easy and difficult to teach. Violence and conflict of the pasts are topics that easily captivates the students. Images in the form of photographs and video-clips on Holocaust can be used for visual presentation to disseminate contents. This is the easy part.
But how to teach values, skills and also check students understanding of lesson in a meaningful way? No doubt the topics of racism and mass murder due to racial/religious differences are sensitive, the topics also create opportunities for teachable moments as well.
For the lesson the students watched a trailer of a movie on Holocaust, Schindler's List, to engage their attention and also to give them a glimpse of what they are going to learn for the lesson. Students were asked questions on what they saw bringing their attention to specific details like "Nazis officials smiling and shooting at the corpses of Jews burning. Students were then posed questions like "What were these Nazis feelings towards Jews. With this students were introduced to Hitler race theory that claims German race to be be Aryan/superior race and Jews as inferior race, who needs to be treated as slaves. Propaganda/anti-semitic posters targeted at the Jews were also shown to the students for them to visualize and understand how Hitler's race theory was put into practice under his rule.
The students were given a summary of other rules that were implemented against the Jews in Germany and how all these eventually led to the execution of the Final Solution to the Jewish Question - the Holocaust (planned and systematic mass murder of the Jews). The students also watched another video-clip on how the were Jews tricked to having a bath in the concentration camps, which eventually turned out to be gas-chambers where the Jews were suffocated to death.
For greater depth, one of the victim's experience, Anne Frank (a Jewish girl who left Germany with her family to Holland and later went to hiding to be safe from Nazis) and her diary was introduced to my students. Images of where the she and her family hid themselves were shown and the students also read 2 selected diary entries of Anne Frank, which described about her family's experience while in hiding. Students definitely got a more insightful learning experience as they had the opportunity to read the experience of a victim of Hitler racial policy.
After a short discussion on the diary entries students were given the following task:
Students are to imagine that Anne Frank survived the concentration camp (she and her family were eventually discovered by the Nazi officials and sent to different concentration camps). They are also to imagine themselves as Anne Frank and write a entry into Anne Frank's diary describing their experiences in the concentration camps, their thoughts and feelings about the experience of the Jews in the camp and their thoughts on Hitler's racial policy. Indeed the objective was to give students an opportunity to be part of history and also to check for their understanding.
The folllowing are two of my students impressive diary entries:
A poem by Amirudy 3E2
Dearest Kitty,
I’m finally out, free from the tortures of Germany’s hell
But I wish I could say the same for the others that fell
Words can’t describe how I currently feel
For my knees kneel tired, my lips dried seal
I’m free from whatever that is contrary to sane
For I don’t want to ‘forget the unforgettable pain
Kitty, how long has it been? Days seemed like years,
When I experienced the sum of all fears
No more gunfire shots that’ll go through souls
My mental distortion shall unfold
Kitty, you are my dearest companion, one I wish I could hold
Because you’re precious to me, prices soar like gold
Now, I’ll pray for those who have lost all hope of life
To the fathers, the mothers, the husbands and wives
I’ll never forget nor forgive what Alois little brother has done
For shadowing the lives of the Jews away from the sun
Bergen-Belsen, that name brings a distasteful bell
Of a place I will forever remember as the camp of hell
Yours Anne
Christialyn Villaflores 3E2
12 April 1946
Dearest Kitty,
It’s been a long time since I last wrote to you. I am happy to see you again my dear. After all that we’ve been through, it’s finally over. We are all free…
A month has passed ever since the humble British liberated us from the evil dictator Hitler and his demons, the Nazis and the SS. We are now living in peace in our new home “Israel.” It mean “struggled with God” like we had to struggle to survive for 2 years under the evil clutches of the Nazis. Kitty it may have been a month since then, but I can still remember the fellow Jews and what I have been though, like it was only yesterday…
It was hot all over. The sun was scorching hot on our heads as we are forcibly working on the dirt. Everyone is hungry and thirsty for we did not have a proper meal in ages. All of us are dry and sticky for we haven’t bathe in days as well. I heard some men whispering among themselves on how to escape. If everyone in this camp looked the same and there were Nazis everywhere, it felt like it was completely impossible for any of us to escape! Men, women and children hair was shaved off by the Nazis.
They were all brutes who showed no mercy to us Jews. I always wanted to kill all of them. But if I do that, it would only feel as if I am like them. Every night I felt like crying whenever I heard the people screaming. The Nazis said that they were only giving the Jews time to “bathe” but later I realized that they were lying when no one came out alive from the “bath chambers.” I was scared to die. What they have done was completely inhumane. They were slaughtering us like dogs! I always asked myself, “Why are they doing this?! We are also humans like them! We all deserve to live. We aren’t just rats for them to trap and kill!”
But now it’s all over. We are finally free. But I still grieve the lost of my mother and sister who had struggled to survive. If all this never happened, they would still be alive, including all those who had suffered and died in the hand of the Nazis.
If I have one wish, I will wish all of this never happened…
Yours Anne
The diary entries of students were generally very insightful,in-depth, heart-warming and some revealed maturity in thoughts about the concept of race, human rights and racism.